Letter to the editor

Former one-term Morgan Hill City Councilmember John K. McKay recently posted on the official Facebook “Steven Hayes Morgan Hill City Council” page, “You’ve been given a solid mandate. Bring our city council back to the days of being a high functioning civil body of decision makers.” 

The photo that Hayes posted with his thank you to supporters featured himself and others, but 30 minutes earlier, there was a different photo—one with a photo-shopped-in picture of our 47th president.

Mr. Hayes, why post that photo? Why remove that photo? Why replace that photo? What are you trying to tell the people of Morgan Hill?

Was the original photograph intended to make a political statement? Was it meant to signal an affiliation, an endorsement or an alignment with a particular political movement? Was it intended to communicate something about the direction you envision for Morgan Hill’s city government?

Did someone suggest that the original photo might be politically divisive? Did you reconsider the message it sent? Did someone ask you to take it down? Was the change prompted by feedback from supporters, concerns about how residents might interpret it or a realization that the image could alienate people who voted for you?

Or was the original photo deliberately chosen to send a message that you subsequently decided was better left unsaid? If the photograph was simply an innocent expression of enthusiasm, why change it? If it was an intentional political statement, why remove it?

You have just been elected to represent the residents of District D, a constituency that includes people with a wide range of political beliefs, values and priorities. 

A city council seat is not a platform for representing one political faction or signaling allegiance to a national political figure. It is a responsibility to serve an entire community.

You’ve been given a mandate, as Mr. McKay put it, but a mandate to do what, exactly? To return to a high functioning, collaborative city council? To advance a particular political ideology? To bring national partisan politics into local government? 

Or to represent all the people who live in Morgan Hill, including those who didn’t vote for you?

The photograph changed. The message, however, may not have. Morgan Hill residents deserve to know what that message was supposed to be.

Karen Fitch

Morgan Hill

Previous articleReligion: Ten years of neighbors becoming friends in the Interfaith Clergy Alliance

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here