Letter to the editor

With ballots already arriving in mailboxes, Morgan Hill voters deserve a real conversation about the future of our city. Unfortunately, one campaign for mayor seems to have just one strategy: attack Mayor Mark Turner.

Scroll through local social media and you’ll see it. Post after post from Deborah Africa’s surrogates, many of them lingering supporters of Councilmember Yvonne Martínez Beltrán, repeat claims about the mayor that are misleading or flatly untrue. Ms. Africa shares this material herself and has done nothing to correct it. 

When a candidate promotes misinformation and stays silent while it spreads, she owns it.

Ms. Africa calls her campaign one of “hope.” Hope in what? Her stated priorities, safe neighborhoods, transparent government, responsible growth, are words every candidate uses. What’s missing is how. How would she pay for public safety? Where would new housing go, and who would serve it with water, sewer, police and fire? 

What would she do about the city’s budget gap? On the rare occasions she gets specific, the answer is raising taxes on residents who are already stretched thin. Residents who ask her for real answers keep getting slogans instead.

A candidate for mayor has an obligation to know the issues: the budget, state housing mandates, builder’s remedy projects on our borders, traffic on 101. 

Leadership isn’t learned on the job when the stakes are this high. Ms. Africa touts her background in healthcare, yet she hasn’t laid out a vision for the community’s health, or much of anything else. This is not the time for Morgan Hill to experiment.

Contrast that with Mayor Turner’s record.

He has kept Morgan Hill safe and earned the endorsement of the Morgan Hill Police Officers’ Association, the Santa Clara County Deputy Sheriffs’ Association, the Gilroy Police Officers’ Association, PORAC and CAL FIRE Local 2881. The people who protect us every day know who has their back.

He has delivered on economic development, bringing new businesses and new jobs to town. He has made youth sports and recreational tourism a priority, turning our parks and fields into an economic engine that fills hotels and restaurants while giving kids a place to play.

He launched the Healthy Morgan Hill initiative. He actively and financially supports the nonprofits that hold our community together. And he shows up, whether it’s a 5am call from a small business owner or a neighborhood meeting on a weeknight.

That’s why more than 75 business leaders, local law enforcement associations and hundreds of community leaders and residents have endorsed him. They’ve seen his work up close.

Campaigns should be about ideas. If Ms. Africa has a plan for Morgan Hill, voters are still waiting to hear it. Mayor Turner has a record we can see and a plan we can measure.

I’ve already cast my ballot to re-elect Mark Turner as Mayor of Morgan Hill. I hope you’ll join me.

Pamala Meador

Morgan Hill

Previous articleLetter: Transparency shouldn’t stop at the school board or the campaign trail
Next articleLetter: Silver Dems put community, values, voters first

4 COMMENTS

  1. I too have been disheartened by the hostility permeating our local elections, and our council meetings. All residents deserve a council that acts in the community’s interests. We deserve a council that can work through problems and find solutions, without personal attacks and vitriol.

    Mayor Turner has always been present and approachable. He cares about Morgan Hill and our city’s future. Our views don’t have to align perfectly for me to know this is true. I hope Tuesday brings needed change so Morgan Hill can move forward.

    • Please sign me up for the newsletter - No
  2. Mark Turner is the incumbent. He’s had his opportunity to lead. If his supporters want to talk about accountability, they should start with the person already holding the office.

    Deborah Africa should have to earn our votes. Mark Turner should have to earn them again.

    Another term is not an entitlement. Vote Deborah Africa.

    • Please sign me up for the newsletter - Yes
  3. Pamala’s letter makes an interesting argument about needing a plan rather than attacks. I agree, but perhaps we should also acknowledge that Pamala has a dog in this fight. As someone who sells real estate in Morgan Hill, she has a professional and financial interest in the city’s image, economic development, and perceived desirability. That doesn’t invalidate her opinion, but it is relevant context when she’s weighing in on who should lead the city.

    What I find particularly interesting is the selective standard of accountability, she wants Deborah Africa to provide specifics, demonstrate qualifications, and explain her plans. Fair enough, but shouldn’t the incumbent mayor be held to precisely the same standard?

    Mark Turner has been touting nearly 900 new jobs, literacy initiatives, agritourism, youth sports tourism, and a host of other accomplishments. Great headlines, but where are the measurable results? How many jobs were actually created? What do they pay? What has been the return on taxpayer investment? What measurable improvements have we seen in literacy? A campaign list is not an accounting of performance, and let’s not confuse criticism with attacks.

    Questioning an elected official’s decisions, conduct, priorities, and results is not an assault on Morgan Hill, it’s civic engagement. In fact, an incumbent should expect considerably more scrutiny than someone asking for the opportunity to serve.

    Endorsements aren’t accomplishments. Being accessible isn’t necessarily being effective. Having a long list of initiatives isn’t the same as demonstrating meaningful results.

    Morgan Hill absolutely needs a plan, it also needs transparency, accountability, collaboration, and leadership that understands the mayor’s role in a council-manager form of government.

    Perhaps the better question isn’t why people are criticizing the incumbent, but why those questions seem to make his supporters so uncomfortable. Voters aren’t obligated to applaud a campaign resume, they’re entitled to examine the actual record. That’s not attacking Morgan Hill, that’s caring enough about the city to expect better.

    • Please sign me up for the newsletter - No
  4. Karen Fitch, Bravo! You articulated some great points quite profoundly! Thank you for your thoughtful writing.

    • Please sign me up for the newsletter - Yes

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here