Do you think seasonal and H1N1 (swine) flu vaccines are
safe?
THIS WEEK’S QUESTION:
“Do you think seasonal and H1N1 (swine) flu vaccines are safe?” Yes: 11 No: 1
? Karen Anderson: “Yes. We get our shots at Kaiser every year where they are very conscientious about asking the right questions to ensure you are a good candidate.”
? Bert Berson: “Yes. Thoughtful balancing of the risks leads me to that conclusion.”
? Chris Bryant: “Yes, they are at least as safe as not getting the shots and taking your chances on catching the flu.”
? David Cohen: “Yes.”
? Dennis Kennedy: “Yes! But compared to what? In light of the high death rates occurring in children and young adults, the risks associated with taking the H1N1 vaccine are less than the risk of catching H1N1 and having serious complications or dying.”
? Julian Mancias: “Yes. But I would never get one.”
? Linda McNulty: “No. Vaccines are never 100 percent safe. Since I work with disabled children I am very leery of most vaccines but in this case I don’t think we have a choice so … it’s a hope and a prayer since long term studies have not been done. Further concerning is the Canadian study, which suggests that people are twice as likely to contract pandemic H1N1 if they have received a seasonal flu shot (which I just got).”
? Henry Miller: “Yes. And I will take advantage of the protection they offer. Have you heard of anyone dying from influenza after receiving shots?”
? Lisa Pampuch: “Yes. Like everything in life, these vaccines carry some risk, in this case quite small when compared to the risks to vulnerable populations of the seasonal or swine flu. To quote Michael Shermer, ‘Vaccination is one of science’s greatest discoveries.’ www.sciencebasedmedicine.org does a great job explaining vaccines.”
? John Quick: “There is no doubt they are safe. There will always be reactions to medications and vaccines. What we look for in public health terms is minimal side effects and maximum benefit. This vaccine provides a huge benefit to counter the tiny frequency of vaccine induced injuries.”
? Emily Shem-Tov: “Yes, I’ve already gotten my seasonal one and plan to get the H1N1 one when it’s available. Clearly there are risks and minor side effects, but the vaccines have good safety records and it not only protects you but lessens the chances you will spread the virus to someone even more at risk.”
? Steve Staloch: “Yes.”
Vote in
